Comrade Detective
- Buddy cop
- Meta historical fiction
- Brian Gatewood
- Alessandro Tanaka
- Brian Gatewood
- Alessandro Tanaka
- Florin Piersic Jr.
- Corneliu Ulici
- Adrian Paduraru
- Olivia Nita
- Florin Galan
- Diana Vladu
- Ion Grosu
- Channing Tatum
- Joseph Gordon-Levitt
- Nick Offerman
- Jenny Slate
- Jason Mantzoukas
- Chloë Sevigny
- Jake Johnson
- John DiMaggio
- Andrew Schneider
- Reid Carolin
- Brian Gatewood
- John Hodges
- Peter Kiernan
- Ravi Nandan
- Alessandro Tanaka
- Channing Tatum
- Rhys Thomas
- Neil Mahoney
- Nicholas Mansour
- A24
- Free Association
- G & T Productions
- Gallivant Films
- Amazon Studios
Comrade Detective is an American buddy cop series created by Brian Gatewood and Alessandro Tanaka. The show follows the premise of popular US action/cop-buddy films and television shows from the 1980s and presents the episodes as a fictional lost Romanian television show commissioned by the Communist Party to promote a communist worldview during the Cold War. Every episode was filmed in Romania using local actors and then dubbed into English as part of the effect.[1] It was released on Amazon Prime Video on August 4, 2017.
Plot
Channing Tatum and Jon Ronson present the show as if it were an actual influential Romanian television show from the 1980s. Produced by the Romanian communist government, it served as a device to promote a communist worldview opposed to Western capitalism and imperialism during the Cold War. Lost over the years, producers recently found surviving copies of the episodes. With the help of the fictional Romanian Film Preservation Society they have restored the episodes and dubbed them into English.
Within the show hard-boiled but troubled Bucharest police detective Gregor Anghel and his partner respond to a drug bust against the orders of their Captain. This results in a man in a Ronald Reagan mask killing his partner in front of him. Anghel, along with his new partner from the countryside, Iosif Baciu, must solve his partner's murder. In doing so, they uncover an insidious western plot to indoctrinate Romanian society with capitalism and religion.
Cast
Each character is portrayed by a Romanian actor, as well as an English-language voice actor. The show was first filmed using Romanian actors speaking Romanian. Actors then over-dubbed every role in English.[1]
Main
- Florin Piersic Jr. as Gregor Anghel
- Channing Tatum as English dub of Gregor Anghel
- Corneliu Ulici as Iosif Baciu
- Joseph Gordon-Levitt as English dub of Iosif Baciu
Recurring
- Adrian Paduraru as Captain Covaci
- Nick Offerman as English dub of Captain Covaci
- Olivia Nita as Jane
- Jenny Slate as English dub of Jane
- Florin Galan as Dragos
- Jason Mantzoukas as English dub of Dragos
- Diana Vladu as Sonya Baciu
- Chloë Sevigny as English dub of Sonya Baciu
- Ion Grosu as Stan
- Jake Johnson as English dub of Stan
- Tipsy Angelo as Tipsy
- John DiMaggio as English dub of Tipsy and several other miscellaneous voice parts
- Channing Tatum as himself
- Jon Ronson as himself
Guest stars
- Richard Bovnoczki as Father Anton Streza
- Daniel Craig as English dub of Father Anton Streza
- Cristian Popa as Nikita Ionescu
- Beck Bennett as English dub of Nikita Ionescu
- Odin Neilsen as Andrei Baciu
- Colleen O'Shaughnessey as English dub of Andrei Baciu
- Vali Pavel as Petre Bubescu
- Bobby Cannavale as English dub of Petre Bubescu
- Radu Romaniuc as Orzan
- Fred Armisen as English dub of Orzan.
- Ille Gâliea as Vasile
- Tracy Letts as English dub of Vasile.
- Ruxandra Enescu as Sally Smith
- Kim Basinger as English dub of Sally Smith
- Silviu Geamanu as Coach
- Mahershala Ali as English dub of Coach
- Ana Ciontea as Iona Anghel
- Debra Winger as English dub of Iona Anghel
- Cornel Ciupercescu as Vlad Anghel
- Richard Jenkins as English dub of Vlad Anghel
- Paul Octavian Diaconescu as Nastase
- Jerrod Carmichael as English dub of Nastase
- Mihai Stefan as Sergiu
- Bo Burnham as English dub of Sergiu
- George Burcea as Todd
- Mark Duplass as English dub of Todd
- Magda Dimitrescu as Tatiana/Trisha
- Katie Aselton as English dub of Tatiana/Trisha
- Nicu Banea as Stefan
- Mark Proksch as English dub of Stefan and several other parts
- Madalin Mladinovici as Markos Miklos
- John Early as the English dub of Markos Miklos and several other parts.
- Cozma Eugeniu as New York Degenerate
- Bobby Lee as English dub of New York Degenerate.
Production
When first conceiving the series, executive producer Channing Tatum asked the creators to bring him the worst ideas they could think of, with the reasoning "When you try to find something that is not working, you figure out what's cool about it, and you can find some really hidden gems."[2] Gatewood and Tanaka pitched a satire series that spoofed Communist propaganda from the 1980s. The two had become fascinated with Soviet propaganda television after seeing a mid-1980s PBS documentary on Soviet broadcasts.[3] They initially looked into dubbing over real Eastern Bloc television shows but realized it would be easier to make their own show rather than procure the rights.[4]
The series takes inspiration from the Czechoslovakian show Thirty Cases of Major Zeman.[2] They also took inspiration from the idea that growing up, American 1980s movies like Red Dawn served as both entertainment and propaganda.[2] It also took inspiration from the East German series Polizeiruf 110 and the American film Lethal Weapon.[5] By making the propaganda and inaccuracies obvious to a western audience, they hoped to make the subtle nature of modern propaganda more clear.[2] Tanaka stated that the goal was to create the inverse Soviet equivalent of the type of Russian-villain entertainment common in 1980s America.[5]
Episodes were initially written in English before being translated into Romanian. The shows were filmed in Romania with local cast.[6] Other than the director of photography, writers and director, the entire cast and crew were locally recruited in Romania.[3] The English-language actors were only cast after the series had been filmed and edited.[6]
In an unlikely coincidence worth mention, the main Romanian actor, Florin Piersic Jr. is the son of Florin Piersic, the main actor of a pretty similar Romanian film series that appeared in 1980–1987, Mărgelatu, which claims the settings of years 1840s-1850s in Romania in 6 episodes: The Road of the Bones (1980), The Yellow Rose (1982), The Mysteries of Bucharest (1983), The Silver Mask (1985), The Turquoise Necklace (1986), and Everything Costs (1987). In the third episode of Mărgelatu, The Mysteries of Bucharest as in The Turquoise Necklace, the two main heroes (Florin Piersic and stunt master Szabolcs Cseh) preempt an attempt by Austrian Empire to foment a revolution as a pretext to invade and take control of the Romanian state found at the time under king Bibescu, in somewhat similarly intricate intrigues and stunts as the ones recalled by Comrade Detective to be happening 150 years later with the atmosphere leading to the 1989 revolution. The police quarters scenes are also similar to the ones in the Brigade Diverse in Alert (1970-1971).
Episodes
No. | Title | Directed by | Written by | Original release date | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | "The Invisible Hand" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
Detective Anghel witnesses his partner's murder. He and his new partner Baciu hunt the man in the Reagan mask. Guest appearances by Kim Basinger, Beck Bennett, Jerrod Carmichael, Bo Burnham, Sandy Martin, John Early, Mark Proksch, and Jon Ronson. | |||||
2 | "No Exit" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
The detectives uncover a conspiracy to smuggle the western board game Monopoly into the country. Guest appearances by Richard Jenkins, Debra Winger, Kimmy Gatewood, Aly Ward Azevedo, Colleen O'Shaughnessey, and Tracy Letts. | |||||
3 | "Bread is Bread" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
Continuing to investigate the murder, the detectives must battle against the forces of organized religion. Guest appearances by Daniel Craig, Betsy Sodaro, John Early, and Jon Ronson. | |||||
4 | "Two Films for One Ticket" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
Undercover, the detectives infiltrate a western-style party full of debauchery and propaganda. Guest appearances by Bobby Cannavale, Mahershala Ali, Fred Armisen, Aly Ward Azevedo, Colleen O'Shaughnessey, John Early, Katie Aselton, Mark Duplass and Bobby Lee. | |||||
5 | "The Whole World is Watching" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
On the run as fugitives, the detectives must seek refuge from an unlikely source: the American embassy. Guest appearances by Aly Ward Azevedo, Colleen O'Shaughnessey, Kate Berlant and Mark Proksch. | |||||
6 | "Survival of the Fittest" | Rhys Thomas | Brian Gatewood, Alex Tanaka | August 4, 2017 (2017-08-04) | |
The two race against time to stop the man in the Reagan mask from claiming another victim. Guest appearances by Daniel Craig, Beck Bennett and Mark Proksch. |
Reception
Comrade Detective received mostly positive reactions from critics. Rotten Tomatoes indicated that 82% of critics gave the series a positive review.[7] On Metacritic the series received a score of 66 out of 100 based on 12 critics.[8]
Ben Travers of IndieWire gave the show a positive review, calling it a sharp satire. He focused in on the show's goal of deconstructing propaganda, claiming, "They're not simply here to make you laugh. They're not here to upset you. They're here to make you think differently and enjoy your time doing it. By that gauge, Comrade Detective is a roaring success. By the basic metric of thoroughly engaging television, it's still a winner."[4]
James Poniewozik of The New York Times gave it a less enthusiastic review, claiming that the show committed too much to its initial joke and ran too long. He concluded, "It's a brilliant idea. But it's not much more than an idea."[9]
See also
References
- ^ a b Stanhope, Kate. "Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Amazon Board Channing Tatum's Romanian Cop-Show Spoof". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved June 29, 2017.
- ^ a b c d Schildhause, Chloe (August 4, 2017). "What the Hell is Comrade Detective?". Vanity Fair. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ a b Breeding, Jordan (August 4, 2017). "How Amazon's Comrade Detective made a long-lost Romanian cop show from scratch". Paste. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ a b Travers, Ben (August 4, 2017). "'Comrade Detective' Review: Channing Tatum's New Cop Drama Is Not What It Seems — It's Better". IndieWire. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ a b Grubbs, Jefferson (August 3, 2017). "Is Comrade Detective based on a true story? The Amazon series creators' have several inspirations". Bustle. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ a b Grubbs, Jefferson (August 3, 2017). "Who are the dubbed voices in Comrade Detective? The Amazon show is a guessing game of famous speech patterns". Bustle. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ "Comrade Detective: Season 1". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ "Comrade Detective: Season 1". Metacritic. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
- ^ Poniewozik, James (August 3, 2017). "Nostalgia Goes Niche in 'Wet Hot American Summer' and 'Comrade Detective'". The New York Times. Retrieved August 6, 2017.
External links
- Comrade Detective at IMDb
- v
- t
- e
- All or Nothing (since 2016)
- Documental (since 2016)
- The Grand Tour (since 2016)
- Sports on Amazon Prime Video (NFL) (since 2017)
- Good Omens (since 2019)
- Making the Cut (since 2020)
- The Test (since 2020)
- Upload (since 2020)
- Clarkson's Farm (since 2021)
- Harlem (since 2021)
- Invincible (since 2021)
- The Outlaws (since 2021)
- Them (since 2021)
- The Wheel of Time (since 2021)
- The Devil's Hour (since 2022)
- Drag Den (since 2022)
- The Lake (since 2022)
- The Legend of Vox Machina (since 2022)
- Lizzo's Watch Out for the Big Grrrls (since 2022)
- The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (since 2022)
- Outer Range (since 2022)
- Reacher (since 2022)
- The Summer I Turned Pretty (since 2022)
- The Terminal List (since 2022)
- Coach Prime (since 2022)
- The Rig (since 2023)
- The Consultant (since 2023)
- Class of '07 (since 2023)
- The Power (since 2023)
- Citadel (since 2023)
- Deadloch (since 2023)
- Twin Love (since 2023)
- Hazbin Hotel (since 2024)
- Mr. & Mrs. Smith (since 2024)
- Dead Hot (since 2024)
- American Rust (since 2024)
- The Baxters (since 2024)
- Fallout (since 2024)
- The 1% Club (since 2024)
The Boys |
|
---|---|
James May |
|
- Crayon Shin-chan Spin-off (2016–17)
- Happy Marriage!? (2016)
- Kamen Rider Amazons (2016–17)
- Ultraman Orb: The Origin Saga (2016–17)
- Baahubali: The Lost Legends (2017–20)
- The Idolmaster KR (since 2017)
- Inside Edge (since 2017)
- Laakhon Mein Ek (2017–19)
- Pushpavalli (2017)
- Tokyo Alice (2017)
- Tokyo Vampire Hotel (2017)
- You Are Wanted (since 2017)
- Banana Fish (2018)
- Breathe (2018)
- Chacha Vidhayak Hain Humare (2018–21)
- Comicstaan (since 2018)
- Diablo Guardián (2018–19)
- Falco (2018)
- Hear Me Love Me (since 2018)
- Inspector Chingum (since 2018)
- Mirzapur (since 2018)
- The Remix (since 2018)
- Shaitaan Haveli (2018)
- Dani Who? (2019)
- De viaje con los Derbez (since 2019)
- El juego de las llaves (since 2019)
- The Family Man (since 2019)
- Four More Shots Please! (since 2019)
- Hernán (since 2019)
- Hostel Daze (since 2019)
- Made in Heaven (since 2019)
- Afsos (since 2020)
- Ana (2020–23)
- Bandish Bandits (since 2020)
- Breathe: Into the Shadows (since 2020)
- El Candidato (since 2020)
- El Presidente (since 2020)
- How to Survive Being Single (since 2020)
- Inés of My Soul (since 2020)
- Pan y Circo (since 2020)
- Panchayat (since 2020)
- Paatal Lok (since 2020)
- Shonan Junai Gumi (2020)
- Time Enna Boss!? (since 2020)
- The Last Hour (since 2021)
- Maradona: Blessed Dream (since 2021)
- The Masked Singer Japan (since 2021)
- September Mornings (since 2021)
- Tandav (since 2021)
- Alexia: Labor Omnia Vincit (2022)
- The Bad Guy (since 2022)
- Guilty Minds (since 2022)
- Kamen Rider Black Sun (2022)
- Miskina, Poor Thing (since 2022)
- Modern Love Mumbai (since 2022)
- Modern Love Hyderabad (since 2022)
- Modern Love Tokyo (since 2022)
- Modern Love Amsterdam (since 2022)
- Prisma (since 2022)
- Short Program (since 2022)
- Suzhal: The Vortex (since 2022)
- Alphonse (since 2023)
- Bambai Meri Jaan (since 2023)
- Dahaad (since 2023)
- Dhootha (since 2023)
- Engga Hostel (since 2023)
- Everybody Loves Diamonds (since 2023)
- Farzi (since 2023)
- Greek Salad (since 2023)
- Happy Family: Conditions Apply (since 2023)
- Jubilee (since 2023)
- Kumari Srimathi (since 2023)
- Los Farad (since 2023)
- Modern Love Chennai (since 2023)
- No Traces (since 2023)
- 007: Road to a Million (since 2023)
- P. I. Meena (since 2023)
- Romancero (since 2023)
- Shehar Lakhot (since 2023)
- The Village (since 2023)
- Bujji and Bhairava (since 2024)
- Dil Dosti Dilemma (since 2024)
- Indian Police Force (since 2024)
- Inspector Rishi (since 2024)
- Jana: Marked for Life (since 2024)
- Maxton Hall — The World Between Us (since 2024)
- Poacher (since 2024)
- Red Queen (since 2024)
- Who Killed Him? (since 2024)
- Betas (2013–14)
- Alpha House (2013–14)
- Bosch (2014–21)
- Gortimer Gibbon's Life on Normal Street (2014–16)
- Hand of God (2014–17)
- Mozart in the Jungle (2014–18)
- Red Oaks (2014–17)
- Ripper Street (2014–16)
- Transparent (2014–19)
- Good Girls Revolt (2015–16)
- Just Add Magic (2015–19)
- The Kicks (2015–16)
- Mad Dogs (2015–16)
- The Man in the High Castle (2015–19)
- One Mississippi (2015–17)
- Patriot (2015–18)
- Sneaky Pete (2015–19)
- Z: The Beginning of Everything (2015–17)
- The Collection (2016)
- Fleabag (2016–19)
- Goliath (2016–21)
- The New Yorker Presents (2016)
- Crisis in Six Scenes (2016)
- I Love Dick (2016–17)
- Jean-Claude Van Johnson (2016–17)
- The Last Tycoon (2016–17)
- The Tick (2016–19)
- American Playboy: The Hugh Hefner Story (2017)
- Comrade Detective (2017)
- Lore (2017–18)
- The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (2017–23)
- Philip K. Dick's Electric Dreams (2018)
- Britannia (2018)
- The Dangerous Book for Boys (2018)
- Forever (2018)
- Gangstars (2018)
- Homecoming (2018–20)
- The Romanoffs (2018)
- Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan (2018–23)
- Carnival Row (2019–23)
- The Expanse (2019–22)
- The Feed (2019)
- Free Meek (2019)
- Hanna (2019–21)
- Lorena (2019)
- Modern Love (2019–21)
- Too Old to Die Young (2019)
- Undone (2019–22)
- The Widow (2019)
- Gary Busey: Pet Judge (2020)
- Hunters (2020–23)
- Just Add Magic: Mystery City (2020)
- Loudermilk (2020)
- The Pack (2020)
- Small Axe (2020)
- Tales from the Loop (2020)
- Ted Bundy: Falling for a Killer (2020)
- Truth Seekers (2020)
- Utopia (2020)
- The Wilds (2020–22)
- World's Toughest Race: Eco-Challenge Fiji (2020)
- Alex Rider (2020–24)
- Back to the Rafters (2021)
- Fairfax (2021–22)
- The Great Escapists (2021)
- I Know What You Did Last Summer (2021)
- LuLaRich (2021)
- Luxe Listings Sydney (2021–22)
- Making Their Mark (2021)
- Panic (2021)
- Solos (2021)
- Tampa Baes (2021)
- Tell Me Your Secrets (2021)
- The Underground Railroad (2021)
- Unicorn Hunters (2021)
- With Love (2021–23)
- As We See It (2022)
- Chloe (2022)
- Cosmic Love (2022)
- Dr. Seuss Baking Challenge (2022)
- The English (2022)
- Forever Summer: Hamptons (2022)
- Good Rivals (2022)
- Jungle (2022)
- The Kids in the Hall (2022)
- The Kids in the Hall: Comedy Punks (2022)
- A League of Their Own (2022)
- Mammals (2022)
- Night Sky (2022)
- The One That Got Away (2022)
- Paper Girls (2022)
- The Peripheral (2022)
- Phat Tuesdays: The Era Of Hip Hop Comedy (2022)
- Pokémon: The Arceus Chronicles (2022; Japan only)
- Riches (2022)
- Ten Percent (2022)
- Three Pines (2022)
- Daisy Jones & the Six (2023)
- Dead Ringers (2023)
- Desperately Seeking Soulmate: Escaping Twin Flames Universe (2023)
- I'm a Virgo (2023)
- Harlan Coben's Shelter (2023)
- The Horror of Dolores Roach (2023)
- The Lost Flowers of Alice Hart (2023)
- Redefined: J. R. Smith (2023)
- The Ride (2023)
- Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets (2023)
- Swarm (2023)
- Wilderness (2023)
- My Man Is Cupid (2023–24)
- Expats (2024)
- Citadel: Diana (2024)
- My Lady Jane (2024)
- Citadel: Honey Bunny (2024)
- Sausage Party: Foodtopia (2024)
- Costiera
- A Higher Calling (TBA)
- Anansi Boys (TBA)
- The Narrow Road to the Deep North (TBA)
- The Night Manager (TBA)